Support Webfit News

Independent journalism needs readers behind it. Help us keep Webfit News free, open and community focused.

Monday, 23 November 2026
Webfit News
SearchNewsroom
Webfit News
Search

Counting down to Christmas

Friday 25 December

Countdown to Christmas
Cricket scoresFull score centre →
News

Attacked in Auckland, Facing Deportation: Why an Indian Student’s Future Now Hangs on Two Legal Battles

Gurleen Bahia, 22, is recovering from a violent robbery in South Auckland while fighting a deportation order and defending theft charges he disputes.

Part of our coverageNZ immigration and visa newsVisa changes, residence and citizenship rules, and migrant worker cases. →
Listen to this articleAudio accessibility
Attacked in Auckland, Facing Deportation: Why an Indian Student’s Future Now Hangs on Two Legal Battles


Gurleen Bahia, 22, is recovering from a violent robbery in South Auckland while fighting a deportation order and defending theft charges he disputes. Immigration New Zealand says it will await the outcome of his criminal proceedings before making decisions about his deportation.

By Webfit News | Auckland | 20 November 2026

Gurleen Bahia came to New Zealand from Punjab in 2024 with a straightforward ambition: to study, gain qualifications and build a future.

Two years later, the 22-year-old is recovering from a violent robbery, facing five theft charges he says arose from someone else’s actions, and fighting a deportation order.

He has no family in New Zealand. Friends are providing him with somewhere to stay, and a local gurdwara is helping with food.

Yet his biggest concern remains unfinished business: his education.

Bahia’s situation was reported by RNZ journalist Blessen Tom on Friday. It raises difficult questions about what happens when an international student’s immigration problems, criminal proceedings and medical needs collide.

One important development offers some clarity. Immigration New Zealand has confirmed it will await the outcome of Bahia’s criminal proceedings before making decisions regarding his deportation.

But that does not mean the deportation order has been cancelled or that his immigration future is secure.

A violent encounter in a Manukau car park

On 19 October, Bahia was parked near Manukau Station Road when someone approached him asking for money.

According to police information provided to RNZ, the person returned shortly afterwards with a group.

One individual allegedly threatened Bahia, demanded money and assaulted him.

Bahia said he was stabbed in a finger and repeatedly struck on the head with the handle of a knife. His phone, wallet and passport were stolen.

Police took him to Middlemore Hospital, where he underwent surgery on his injured finger.

The recovery has been difficult. Bahia told RNZ that he was still receiving treatment and could not stand or walk for extended periods.

He said surgical wires and screws were due to be removed after eight weeks.

Police located a vehicle of interest on the day of the attack and spoke with its occupants. However, officers said there was insufficient evidence to make an arrest.

The aggravated robbery investigation remains ongoing.

His visa problems started months earlier

There is an important distinction in Bahia’s case: the robbery did not start his immigration difficulties.

After arriving in New Zealand in 2024, Bahia completed a Level 5 Diploma in Ageing and Disability Services.

He subsequently enrolled in a Level 7 Diploma in Community Healthcare and Support.

However, family difficulties affected his attendance, and he was unable to complete the second qualification.

An attempt to extend his visa in April 2026 was unsuccessful. He applied for another student visa in June, but Immigration New Zealand declined that application too.

The precise grounds for those decisions have not been established in the information available to Webfit News.

By the time the robbery occurred in October, Bahia was already dealing with an uncertain immigration situation.

The second legal battle: Five theft charges

Bahia is also facing criminal proceedings relating to alleged petrol thefts in August.

He has been charged with five counts of theft after a former flatmate allegedly used his car to obtain fuel without paying.

Bahia disputes responsibility.

He told RNZ he was unaware of the alleged offending and had always paid for his own petrol.

He also alleged that the same person stole his laptop and phone before blocking contact with him.

Those allegations have not been established in court.

Being charged with an offence is not the same as being convicted. Bahia’s criminal proceedings remain unresolved, and he is due to appear in court again on 15 December.

While attending court earlier this month, he was served with a deportation order by Immigration Compliance.

The combination of the unresolved criminal case, immigration proceedings and medical recovery has left him in an exceptionally difficult position.

Immigration NZ says it will wait

Immigration New Zealand has provided an important update on Bahia’s situation.

Steve Watson, the agency’s Immigration Compliance and Investigations general manager, told RNZ that relevant information would be considered in the deportation decision-making process, including any request to cancel the order.

The agency also confirmed it would await the outcome of Bahia’s criminal proceedings before making decisions regarding his deportation.

This means there are still decisions to be made.

However, the distinction between a deportation order being served and that order being cancelled is crucial. No cancellation has been confirmed.

Bahia’s immigration adviser, Jagdeep Singh Sidhu, president of the NZ Forum for Immigration Professionals, has applied to have the deportation order cancelled.

Sidhu says Bahia wants to complete his studies and continue receiving medical treatment.

Immigration lawyer Mathew Harrington of Queen City Law told RNZ that the available options are limited, although immigration authorities have powers to consider exceptional personal circumstances.

Whether those powers will be exercised in Bahia’s favour remains unknown.

The timeline: How the situation developed

When

What happened

2024

Bahia arrives in New Zealand to study

2024–2026

Completes Level 5 and enrols in Level 7 studies

April 2026

Visa extension attempt unsuccessful

June 2026

New student visa application declined

August 2026

Alleged petrol thefts involving his vehicle

19 October

Assaulted and robbed in Manukau

November

Served with a deportation order

20 November

Immigration NZ’s position reported by RNZ

15 December

Next scheduled criminal court appearance

What other international students should know

Bahia’s experience highlights several immigration rules that students may not fully understand until something goes wrong.

1. Missing classes can affect future visa applications

Student visa holders are generally expected to attend their courses and make satisfactory academic progress.

Immigration New Zealand recognises that students can have genuine reasons for absences, but those circumstances may need to be explained and supported with evidence when applying for another visa.

Medical certificates, academic records and correspondence with education providers can be important.

An absence does not automatically lead to deportation.

2. An expired visa and a deportation order are different situations

A person who becomes unlawful in New Zealand may, in some circumstances, request a visa under section 61 of the Immigration Act 2009.

However, Immigration New Zealand’s published guidance states that a section 61 visa cannot be granted after a deportation order has been issued.

At that stage, different legal processes and discretionary powers may become relevant.

This is why obtaining qualified advice early is important.

3. Being a crime victim does not automatically protect immigration status

New Zealand does not have a general immigration visa category specifically for victims of crime, according to immigration lawyer Mathew Harrington’s explanation to RNZ.

A person’s medical condition and other circumstances may be relevant to discretionary immigration decisions, but they do not automatically establish a right to remain.

4. Criminal charges and convictions must not be confused

An unresolved criminal charge does not establish guilt.

Criminal proceedings and immigration decisions operate under different legal frameworks, although the outcome of a criminal case may become relevant to immigration authorities.

Students facing both issues should obtain advice from appropriately qualified legal professionals.

Where students can seek help

International students experiencing serious difficulties can contact several organisations, depending on their circumstances.

Situation

Where to seek help

Visa concerns or declined applications

Immigration New Zealand or a licensed immigration adviser

Deportation notices or orders

Immigration lawyer or licensed immigration adviser urgently

Problems with attendance or course completion

Education provider’s international student support team

Assault, threats or theft

New Zealand Police, 111 for emergencies or 105 for non-emergencies

Support following a crime

Victim Support New Zealand

Disputes with an education provider

NZQA or the relevant student complaints service

Students should not assume that reporting a crime, applying for medical leave or having an unresolved court case automatically extends their visa.

A community stepping in where family cannot

While the legal processes continue, Bahia is relying on people around him.

According to his adviser, he has no family in New Zealand. Friends are allowing him to stay without paying rent, and a local gurdwara has been providing food.

That support is helping him recover from the attack, but his longer-term situation remains uncertain.

His next court appearance is scheduled for 15 December. Immigration New Zealand has said it will await the outcome of the criminal proceedings before making decisions regarding deportation.

There are still important unanswered questions, including the precise grounds for his visa refusals, the evidence being considered in the request to cancel his deportation order, and how his ongoing treatment may affect the process.

None of those questions should be answered through speculation.

For Bahia, the immediate priorities are recovering from his injuries, responding to the charges before the court and resolving his immigration situation.

Beyond the legal complexities, his original ambition has not changed.

He wants to finish his education.

And for thousands of other international students navigating life far from home, his experience illustrates how quickly an unexpected crisis can become much more complicated when visa conditions, legal proceedings and personal hardship overlap.


Source and reporting note: Gurleen Bahia’s circumstances, the police investigation, statements from immigration professionals and Immigration New Zealand’s response were originally reported by Blessen Tom for RNZ on 20 November 2026. Webfit News has expanded on the case with a chronological breakdown, explanations of relevant immigration rules and practical guidance for international students. Webfit News has not independently interviewed Bahia or the authorities involved.


Share
Follow

Was this article useful?

ImmigrationCrime & Courts
Related

More on this story

From the newsroom

Keep reading

Back to homepage